Sharepoint-Toolbox/.planning/milestones/v1.0-phases/01-foundation/01-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score, re_verification

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification
01-foundation	2026-04-02T11:15:00Z	passed	11/11 must-haves verified	false

Phase 1: Foundation Verification Report

Phase Goal: Establish the complete WPF .NET 10 application skeleton with authentication infrastructure, persistence layer, localization system, and all shared patterns that every subsequent phase will build upon. Verified: 2026-04-02T11:15:00Z Status: PASSED Re-verification: No — initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	dotnet test produces zero failures (44 pass, 1 skip for interactive MSAL)	VERIFIED	Live run: Failed=0, Passed=44, Skipped=1, Total=45, Duration=192ms
2	Solution contains two projects (SharepointToolbox WPF + SharepointToolbox.Tests xUnit)	VERIFIED	SharepointToolbox.slnx references both .csproj files; both directories confirmed
3	App.xaml has no StartupUri; Generic Host entry point with [STAThread] Main	VERIFIED	App.xaml confirmed no StartupUri; App.xaml.cs has [STAThread] + Host.CreateDefaultBuilder
4	All NuGet packages present with correct versions; PublishTrimmed=false	VERIFIED	csproj: CommunityToolkit.Mvvm 8.4.2, MSAL 4.83.3, PnP.Framework 1.18.0, Serilog 4.3.1
5	Core models, messages, and infrastructure helpers provide typed contracts	VERIFIED	TenantProfile, OperationProgress, TenantSwitchedMessage, LanguageChangedMessage, helpers
6	Persistence layer uses write-then-replace with SemaphoreSlim(1); JSON schema matches live data	VERIFIED	ProfileRepository.cs and SettingsRepository.cs both implement .tmp + File.Move pattern
7	Authentication layer provides per-ClientId MSAL PCA isolation; SessionManager is sole holder	VERIFIED	MsalClientFactory has per-clientId Dictionary + SemaphoreSlim; SessionManager confirmed
8	TranslationSource enables runtime culture switching without restart	VERIFIED	TranslationSource.cs: PropertyChangedEventArgs(string.Empty) on culture change
9	Serilog wired to rolling file + LogPanelSink; ILogger injectable via DI	VERIFIED	App.xaml.cs wires LogPanelSink after MainWindow resolved; all services use ILogger
10	WPF shell shows toolbar, 8-tab TabControl with FeatureTabBase, log panel, live StatusBar	VERIFIED	MainWindow.xaml confirmed: ToolBar, 8 TabItems (7 with FeatureTabBase), RichTextBox x:Name="LogPanel", StatusBar with ProgressStatus binding
11	ProfileManagementDialog + SettingsView complete Phase 1 UX; language switch immediate	VERIFIED	Both views exist with DI injection; SettingsTabItem.Content set from code-behind; FR translations confirmed real (Connexion, Annuler, Langue)

Score: 11/11 truths verified

---

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Provides	Status	Details
SharepointToolbox.slnx	Solution with both projects	VERIFIED	Exists; .slnx format (dotnet new sln in .NET 10 SDK)
SharepointToolbox/SharepointToolbox.csproj	WPF .NET 10 project with all NuGet packages	VERIFIED	Contains PublishTrimmed=false, StartupObject, all 9 packages
SharepointToolbox/App.xaml.cs	Generic Host entry point with [STAThread]	VERIFIED	[STAThread] Main, Host.CreateDefaultBuilder, LogPanelSink wiring, DI reg
SharepointToolbox/App.xaml	No StartupUri; BoolToVisibilityConverter	VERIFIED	No StartupUri; BooleanToVisibilityConverter resource present
SharepointToolbox.Tests/SharepointToolbox.Tests.csproj	xUnit test project referencing main project	VERIFIED	References main project; xunit 2.9.3; Moq 4.20.72; net10.0-windows
SharepointToolbox/Core/Models/TenantProfile.cs	Profile model with TenantUrl field	VERIFIED	Plain class; Name/TenantUrl/ClientId matching JSON schema
SharepointToolbox/Core/Models/OperationProgress.cs	Shared progress record for IProgress	VERIFIED	record OperationProgress with Indeterminate factory
SharepointToolbox/Core/Models/AppSettings.cs	Settings model with DataFolder + Lang	VERIFIED	Exists in Core/Models; camelCase-compatible
SharepointToolbox/Core/Messages/TenantSwitchedMessage.cs	WeakReferenceMessenger broadcast message	VERIFIED	Extends ValueChangedMessage
SharepointToolbox/Core/Messages/LanguageChangedMessage.cs	Language change broadcast message	VERIFIED	Extends ValueChangedMessage
SharepointToolbox/Core/Messages/ProgressUpdatedMessage.cs	StatusBar live update message	VERIFIED	Extends ValueChangedMessage
SharepointToolbox/Core/Helpers/SharePointPaginationHelper.cs	CSOM pagination via ListItemCollectionPosition	VERIFIED	Contains ListItemCollectionPosition do/while loop; [EnumeratorCancellation]
SharepointToolbox/Core/Helpers/ExecuteQueryRetryHelper.cs	Throttle-aware retry with IProgress surfacing	VERIFIED	ExecuteQueryRetryAsync with exponential backoff; IProgress
SharepointToolbox/Infrastructure/Logging/LogPanelSink.cs	ILogEventSink writing to RichTextBox via Dispatcher	VERIFIED	Implements ILogEventSink; uses Application.Current?.Dispatcher.InvokeAsync
SharepointToolbox/Infrastructure/Auth/MsalClientFactory.cs	Per-ClientId IPublicClientApplication + cache	VERIFIED	SemaphoreSlim; per-clientId Dictionary; MsalCacheHelper; GetCacheHelper()
SharepointToolbox/Infrastructure/Persistence/ProfileRepository.cs	File I/O with SemaphoreSlim + write-then-replace	VERIFIED	SemaphoreSlim(1,1); .tmp write + JsonDocument.Parse + File.Move
SharepointToolbox/Infrastructure/Persistence/SettingsRepository.cs	Settings file I/O with write-then-replace	VERIFIED	Same pattern as ProfileRepository; camelCase serialization
SharepointToolbox/Services/ProfileService.cs	CRUD on TenantProfile with validation	VERIFIED	54 lines; GetProfilesAsync/AddProfileAsync/RenameProfileAsync/DeleteProfileAsync
SharepointToolbox/Services/SettingsService.cs	Get/SetLanguage/SetDataFolder with validation	VERIFIED	39 lines; validates "en"/"fr" only; delegates to SettingsRepository
SharepointToolbox/Services/SessionManager.cs	Singleton holding all ClientContext instances	VERIFIED	IsAuthenticated/GetOrCreateContextAsync/ClearSessionAsync; NormalizeUrl
SharepointToolbox/Localization/TranslationSource.cs	Singleton INotifyPropertyChanged string lookup	VERIFIED	PropertyChangedEventArgs(string.Empty) on culture switch; missing key returns "[key]"
SharepointToolbox/Localization/Strings.resx	27 EN Phase 1 UI strings	VERIFIED	29 data entries confirmed; all required keys present (tab., toolbar., etc.)
SharepointToolbox/Localization/Strings.fr.resx	27 FR keys with real translations	VERIFIED	29 data entries; real French strings confirmed: Connexion, Annuler, Langue
SharepointToolbox/Localization/Strings.Designer.cs	ResourceManager accessor for dotnet build	VERIFIED	Exists; manually maintained; no VS ResXFileCodeGenerator dependency
SharepointToolbox/ViewModels/FeatureViewModelBase.cs	Abstract base with CancellationTokenSource lifecycle	VERIFIED	CancellationTokenSource; RunCommand/CancelCommand; IProgress
SharepointToolbox/ViewModels/MainWindowViewModel.cs	Shell ViewModel with TenantProfiles + ProgressStatus	VERIFIED	ObservableCollection; TenantSwitchedMessage dispatch; ProgressUpdatedMessage subscription
SharepointToolbox/ViewModels/ProfileManagementViewModel.cs	CRUD dialog ViewModel	VERIFIED	Exists; AddCommand/RenameCommand/DeleteCommand
SharepointToolbox/ViewModels/Tabs/SettingsViewModel.cs	Language + folder settings ViewModel	VERIFIED	BrowseFolderCommand; delegates to SettingsService
SharepointToolbox/Views/Controls/FeatureTabBase.xaml	Reusable UserControl with ProgressBar + Cancel	VERIFIED	ProgressBar + TextBlock + Button; Visibility bound to IsRunning via BoolToVisibilityConverter
SharepointToolbox/Views/MainWindow.xaml	WPF shell with toolbar, TabControl, log panel	VERIFIED	RichTextBox x:Name="LogPanel"; 7 FeatureTabBase tabs; StatusBar ProgressStatus binding
SharepointToolbox/Views/Dialogs/ProfileManagementDialog.xaml	Modal dialog for profile CRUD	VERIFIED	Window; 3 input fields (Name/TenantUrl/ClientId); TranslationSource bindings
SharepointToolbox/Views/Tabs/SettingsView.xaml	Settings tab with language + folder controls	VERIFIED	Language ComboBox (en/fr); DataFolder TextBox; BrowseFolderCommand button
All 7 test files	Unit/integration tests (728 lines total)	VERIFIED	ProfileServiceTests 172L, SettingsServiceTests 123L, MsalClientFactoryTests 75L, SessionManagerTests 103L, FeatureViewModelBaseTests 125L, TranslationSourceTests 83L, LoggingIntegrationTests 47L

---

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
App.xaml.cs	App.xaml	x:Class + no StartupUri + Page not ApplicationDefinition	VERIFIED	App.xaml has no StartupUri; csproj demotes to Page
App.xaml.cs	LogPanelSink	LoggerConfiguration.WriteTo.Sink(new LogPanelSink(mainWindow.GetLogPanel()))	VERIFIED	Line 48 of App.xaml.cs confirmed wired
App.xaml.cs	All DI services	RegisterServices — all 10 services registered	VERIFIED	ProfileRepository, SettingsRepository, MsalClientFactory, SessionManager, ProfileService, SettingsService, MainWindowViewModel, ProfileManagementViewModel, SettingsViewModel, MainWindow, ProfileManagementDialog, SettingsView
MainWindowViewModel	TenantSwitchedMessage	WeakReferenceMessenger.Default.Send in OnSelectedProfileChanged	VERIFIED	Confirmed in MainWindowViewModel.cs line 72
MainWindowViewModel	ProgressUpdatedMessage	Messenger.Register in OnActivated — updates ProgressStatus	VERIFIED	ProgressStatus and ProgressPercentage updated in OnActivated
MainWindow.xaml StatusBar	ProgressStatus	Binding Content={Binding ProgressStatus}	VERIFIED	Line 31 of MainWindow.xaml confirmed
MainWindow.xaml stub tabs	FeatureTabBase	TabItem Content = controls:FeatureTabBase	VERIFIED	7 of 8 tabs use FeatureTabBase; SettingsTabItem uses DI-resolved SettingsView
MainWindow.xaml.cs	SettingsView (via DI)	SettingsTabItem.Content = serviceProvider.GetRequiredService()	VERIFIED	Line 24 of MainWindow.xaml.cs confirmed
MainWindow.xaml.cs	ProfileManagementDialog factory	viewModel.OpenProfileManagementDialog = () => serviceProvider.GetRequiredService()	VERIFIED	Line 21 confirmed
FeatureViewModelBase	ProgressUpdatedMessage	WeakReferenceMessenger.Default.Send in Progress callback	VERIFIED	Line 49 of FeatureViewModelBase.cs
SessionManager	MsalClientFactory	_msalFactory.GetOrCreateAsync + GetCacheHelper (tokenCacheCallback)	VERIFIED	SessionManager.cs lines 56-72 confirmed
ProfileRepository	Sharepoint_Export_profiles.json	{ "profiles": [...] } wrapper via camelCase STJ	VERIFIED	ProfilesRoot class with Profiles list; camelCase serialization
SettingsRepository	Sharepoint_Settings.json	{ "dataFolder", "lang" } via camelCase STJ	VERIFIED	SettingsRepository.cs with camelCase serialization
TranslationSource	Strings.resx	Strings.ResourceManager (via Strings.Designer.cs)	VERIFIED	TranslationSource.cs line 17: Strings.ResourceManager

---

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Plans	Description	Status	Evidence
FOUND-01	01, 06, 08	WPF .NET 10 + MVVM architecture	SATISFIED	SharepointToolbox.csproj net10.0-windows + UseWPF; CommunityToolkit.Mvvm; FeatureViewModelBase + MainWindowViewModel MVVM pattern
FOUND-02	03, 07, 08	Multi-tenant profile registry (create/rename/delete/switch)	SATISFIED	ProfileService CRUD + ProfileManagementDialog UI; ProfileServiceTests 10 tests pass
FOUND-03	04, 08	MSAL token cache per tenant; authenticated across tenant switches	SATISFIED	MsalClientFactory per-clientId PCA + MsalCacheHelper; SessionManager caches ClientContext
FOUND-04	04, 08	Interactive Azure AD OAuth login via browser; no secrets stored	SATISFIED	SessionManager.GetOrCreateContextAsync uses AuthenticationManager.CreateWithInteractiveLogin; no client secrets in code
FOUND-05	02, 06, 08	Long-running operations report progress in real-time	SATISFIED	OperationProgress record; IProgress in FeatureViewModelBase; ProgressUpdatedMessage to StatusBar
FOUND-06	06, 08	User can cancel any long-running operation	SATISFIED	CancellationTokenSource lifecycle in FeatureViewModelBase; CancelCommand; FeatureTabBase Cancel button
FOUND-07	02, 06, 08	Errors surface with actionable messages; no silent failures	SATISFIED	Global DispatcherUnhandledException + TaskScheduler.UnobservedTaskException; FeatureViewModelBase catches Exception; LogPanelSink colors errors red
FOUND-08	02, 05, 08	Structured logging (Serilog)	SATISFIED	Serilog 4.3.1 + Serilog.Sinks.File + Serilog.Extensions.Hosting; rolling daily log; LogPanelSink for in-app panel
FOUND-09	05, 07, 08	Localization supporting EN and FR with dynamic language switching	SATISFIED	TranslationSource.Instance; PropertyChangedEventArgs(string.Empty); SettingsView language ComboBox; real FR translations
FOUND-10	03, 08	JSON-based local storage compatible with current app format for migration	SATISFIED	ProfileRepository uses { "profiles": [...] } schema; camelCase field names match existing JSON
FOUND-11	Phase 5	Self-contained single EXE distribution (deferred)	N/A	Explicitly deferred to Phase 5 — not in scope for Phase 1
FOUND-12	03, 07, 08	Configurable data output folder for exports	SATISFIED	SettingsService.SetDataFolderAsync; SettingsView DataFolder TextBox + Browse button; persists to settings.json

Orphaned requirements: None — all Phase 1 requirements are claimed by plans. FOUND-11 is correctly assigned to Phase 5.

---

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
ViewModels/Tabs/SettingsViewModel.cs	92	throw new NotSupportedException(...) in RunOperationAsync	INFO	Intentional — Settings tab has no long-running operation; per-plan design decision

No blockers or warnings found. The single NotSupportedException is by design — SettingsViewModel extends FeatureViewModelBase but has no long-running operation; the throw is the correct implementation per the plan spec.

Build note: dotnet build produces MSB3026/MSB3027 file-lock errors because the application is currently running (process 4480 has the .exe locked). These are environment-state errors, not source code compilation errors. The test suite ran successfully with --no-build (44/44 pass), confirming the previously compiled artifacts are correct. Source code itself has 0 C# errors or warnings.

---

Human Verification Required

The following items were confirmed by human during plan 01-08 visual checkpoint and cannot be re-verified programmatically:

1. WPF Shell Launch and Layout

Test: Run dotnet run --project SharepointToolbox/SharepointToolbox.csproj Expected: Window shows toolbar at top, 8-tab TabControl, 150px log panel (black background, green text), status bar at bottom Why human: Visual layout cannot be verified by grep; WPF rendering requires runtime Status: Confirmed by human in plan 01-08 (2026-04-02)

2. Dynamic Language Switching

Test: Open Settings tab, change to French, observe tab headers change immediately Expected: Tab headers switch to French without restart Why human: Runtime WPF binding behavior; TranslationSource.PropertyChanged must actually trigger binding refresh Status: Confirmed by human in plan 01-08 (2026-04-02)

3. Profile Management Dialog

Test: Click "Manage Profiles...", add/rename/delete a profile, verify toolbar ComboBox updates Expected: Modal dialog opens; all 3 CRUD operations work; ComboBox refreshes after dialog closes Why human: Dialog modal flow; ComboBox refresh timing; runtime interaction required Status: Confirmed by human in plan 01-08 (2026-04-02)

4. Log Panel Rendering

Test: Observe startup messages in log panel Expected: Timestamped entries in HH:mm:ss [LEVEL] message format; info=green, warn=orange, error=red Why human: WPF RichTextBox rendering; color coding; Dispatcher dispatch timing Status: Confirmed by human in plan 01-08 (2026-04-02)

5. MSAL Interactive Login Flow

Test: Select a profile with real Azure AD ClientId + TenantUrl, click Connect Expected: Browser/WAM opens for interactive authentication; on success, connection established Why human: Requires real Azure AD tenant; browser interaction; cannot run in automated test Status: Intentionally deferred to Phase 2 integration testing — infrastructure in place

---

Gaps Summary

No gaps found. All 11 observable truths are verified. All 11 requirement IDs (FOUND-01 through FOUND-12, excluding FOUND-11 which is Phase 5) are satisfied. All required artifacts exist and are substantive. All key links are wired and confirmed by code inspection.

The phase goal is fully achieved: the application has a complete WPF .NET 10 skeleton with:

• Generic Host + DI container wired
• Per-tenant MSAL authentication infrastructure (no interactive login in tests — expected)
• Write-then-replace file persistence with JSON schema compatibility
• Runtime culture-switching localization (EN + real FR translations)
• FeatureViewModelBase pattern establishing the async/cancel/progress contract for all feature phases
• WPF shell with toolbar, 8-tab TabControl, log panel, and live status bar
• 44 automated tests green; 1 interactive MSAL test correctly skipped

---

Verified: 2026-04-02T11:15:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)