Ready2Blob/.planning/phases/11-polish-responsiveness/11-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score, re_verification, human_verification

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification	human_verification
11-polish-responsiveness	2026-04-01T13:35:00Z	passed	10/10 must-haves verified	false	test expected why_human Resize browser to <640px viewport and navigate through all wizard steps Backend cards stack in a single column, navigation buttons fill full width and stack vertically, StepIndicator shows only circles/connectors (no labels) CSS responsive breakpoints cannot be tested by grep; requires actual viewport resize test expected why_human Navigate wizard with keyboard only (Tab + Enter/Space) Every button, card, and theme toggle button shows a visible 3px indigo focus ring when focused via keyboard; no ring appears when clicking with mouse focus-visible CSS behavior requires actual browser rendering to verify visually test expected why_human Click through wizard steps (step 1 to step 2, etc.) Each new step content fades in and slides up by ~8px over 200ms CSS animation playback requires browser rendering test expected why_human Enable prefers-reduced-motion (OS accessibility setting or DevTools) and navigate steps Step transitions show no animation — content appears instantly prefers-reduced-motion media query behavior requires OS/browser setting and visual inspection test expected why_human On BackendSelectionStep, click Next without filling in the remote name Page scrolls smoothly to center the remote name input in the viewport scrollIntoView behavior in real browser differs from jsdom mock; visual scroll feedback requires browser test expected why_human On RemoteConfigStep (e.g. S3 backend), click Next without filling required fields Page scrolls smoothly to center the first errored field in the viewport Same as above — real scroll behavior needs browser verification

Phase 11: Polish & Responsiveness Verification Report

Phase Goal: The wizard feels production-ready on any device with smooth interactions and accessible keyboard navigation Verified: 2026-04-01T13:35:00Z Status: passed Re-verification: No — initial verification

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	On mobile viewport (<640px), backend cards stack vertically in a single column	VERIFIED	BackendSelectionStep.tsx:80 — grid grid-cols-1 sm:grid-cols-2
2	On mobile viewport (<640px), navigation buttons stretch to full width and stack vertically	VERIFIED	All 4 step components have flex flex-col sm:flex-row wrapper + w-full sm:w-auto on buttons
3	On mobile viewport (<640px), StepIndicator hides label text but keeps circles and connectors	VERIFIED	StepIndicator.tsx:45,52,59 — all 3 label spans have hidden sm:block
4	On desktop viewport (>=640px), backend cards display in a 2-column grid	VERIFIED	BackendSelectionStep.tsx:80 — sm:grid-cols-2 activates at 640px+
5	Every button and interactive card shows a 3px MD3 focus ring when keyboard-navigated	VERIFIED	md3-buttons.ts:14,20,26 — all constants have focus-visible:ring-3 focus-visible:ring-primary; BackendCard.tsx:17; ThemeToggle.tsx:61,62; StepIndicator.tsx:42
6	Focus ring does not appear on mouse click (uses focus-visible, not focus)	VERIFIED	All interactive elements consistently use focus-visible: prefix, not bare focus:
7	Changing wizard steps plays a subtle fade/slide-up animation on the new step content	VERIFIED	App.tsx:65 — key={state.currentStep} className="mt-8 animate-step-in" forces remount; index.css:72-81 — @keyframes step-in with opacity 0→1, translateY(8px)→0
8	Users with prefers-reduced-motion enabled see no animation on step change	VERIFIED	index.css:83-87 — @media (prefers-reduced-motion: reduce) { .animate-step-in { animation: none !important; } }
9	When form validation fails, the view auto-scrolls to the first errored field	VERIFIED	BackendSelectionStep.tsx:53-56 — onInvalidSubmit calls getElementById('remote-name')?.scrollIntoView; RemoteConfigStep.tsx:46-51 — onInvalidSubmit resolves first error key and scrolls
10	scrollIntoView uses smooth behavior and centers the errored field	VERIFIED	Both components use { behavior: 'smooth', block: 'center' }

Score: 10/10 truths verified

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	MD3 button constants with focus-visible:ring-3	VERIFIED	Lines 14, 20, 26 — all three constants contain focus-visible:ring-3 focus-visible:ring-primary
src/components/ui/BackendCard.tsx	Responsive full-width card with focus-visible ring	VERIFIED	Line 17 — base class includes w-full and focus-visible:ring-3 focus-visible:ring-primary
src/components/wizard/StepIndicator.tsx	Collapsed labels on mobile, upgraded focus ring	VERIFIED	Lines 45, 52, 59 — hidden sm:block on all 3 label spans; line 42 — group-focus-visible:ring-3
src/components/wizard/BackendSelectionStep.tsx	Responsive card grid and button row	VERIFIED	Line 80 — grid grid-cols-1 sm:grid-cols-2; line 91 — flex flex-col sm:flex-row
src/index.css	step-in keyframe animation and reduced-motion guard	VERIFIED	Line 69 — --animate-step-in in @theme; lines 72-81 — @keyframes step-in; lines 83-87 — reduced-motion guard
src/App.tsx	Step content wrapper with key and animation class	VERIFIED	Line 65 — key={state.currentStep} className="mt-8 animate-step-in"
src/components/wizard/BackendSelectionStep.tsx (scroll)	Auto-scroll to first error on validation failure	VERIFIED	Lines 53-56 — onInvalidSubmit wired to handleSubmit on both form onSubmit and handleCardClick
src/components/wizard/RemoteConfigStep.tsx	Auto-scroll to first error on validation failure	VERIFIED	Lines 46-51 — onInvalidSubmit wired to form handleSubmit

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	All step components	MD3_BTN_FILLED / MD3_BTN_OUTLINED constants	WIRED	Imported and used in BackendSelectionStep, RemoteConfigStep, DeploymentStep, ReviewStep
src/components/ui/BackendCard.tsx	BackendSelectionStep.tsx	Component usage	WIRED	Imported line 8 and rendered in grid at line 82
src/index.css	src/App.tsx	animate-step-in Tailwind utility	WIRED	--animate-step-in registered in @theme; animate-step-in applied in App.tsx line 65
BackendSelectionStep.tsx	DOM element #remote-name	document.getElementById('remote-name')?.scrollIntoView	WIRED	onInvalidSubmit wired as second arg to handleSubmit at lines 60, 70
RemoteConfigStep.tsx	DOM element by first error key	document.getElementById(firstKey)?.scrollIntoView	WIRED	onInvalidSubmit wired as second arg to handleSubmit at line 70

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Source Plan	Description	Status	Evidence
POLISH-01	11-01	Wizard layout adapts to mobile screens — backend cards stack, form fields go full-width, step indicator collapses, buttons stretch	SATISFIED	grid grid-cols-1 sm:grid-cols-2 on card container; flex flex-col sm:flex-row + w-full sm:w-auto on all button rows; hidden sm:block on all StepIndicator labels
POLISH-02	11-01	All interactive elements have visible MD3 focus indicators (3px outline) using focus-visible for keyboard navigation	SATISFIED	All three MD3_BTN constants use focus-visible:ring-3; BackendCard, ThemeToggle, StepIndicator completed-step circle, and both FieldRenderer tooltip buttons all have focus-visible rings
POLISH-03	11-02	Step transitions use subtle fade/slide animation that respects prefers-reduced-motion	SATISFIED	@keyframes step-in with 200ms ease-out in index.css; key={state.currentStep} animate-step-in in App.tsx; @media (prefers-reduced-motion: reduce) guard
POLISH-04	11-02	On validation failure, the view auto-scrolls to the first errored field	SATISFIED	Both BackendSelectionStep and RemoteConfigStep implement onInvalidSubmit with scrollIntoView({ behavior: 'smooth', block: 'center' }); unit tests verify behavior (204 tests pass)

No orphaned requirements — all four POLISH-xx IDs declared in REQUIREMENTS.md are claimed by plans 11-01 and 11-02.

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
src/components/ui/FieldRenderer.tsx	71	focus:ring-error/50 and focus:ring-primary/50 on select element — ring color uses bare focus: while ring width uses focus-visible:ring-2	Info	Inconsistency only — no functional impact. Ring width (ring-2) is gated on focus-visible, so the color class is dormant on mouse click. Visual behavior is correct.

No blocker or warning anti-patterns found. The single info-level item in FieldRenderer is a harmless inconsistency: the ring size was correctly changed to focus-visible:ring-2 per the plan, but the color selectors (focus:ring-error/50, focus:ring-primary/50) retain the bare focus: prefix. Because the ring width class controls visibility, the color classes are inert during mouse focus. The plan only required changing the size class, so this is within spec.

Human Verification Required

1. Mobile layout at <640px viewport

Test: Open the wizard in a browser, resize the viewport to 375px wide, and navigate through all four steps. Expected: Backend cards appear one per row (full width); Back/Next buttons fill the full width and stack vertically (Back on top, Next below); StepIndicator shows only the numbered circles with connector lines — no "Backend", "Remote Config", "Deployment", "Review" labels. Why human: Tailwind responsive breakpoints (sm: prefix = 640px) require actual viewport rendering; grep confirms the classes exist but cannot confirm Tailwind compiles and applies them correctly.

2. Keyboard focus rings (focus-visible behavior)

Test: Tab through all wizard interactive elements (theme toggle, step indicator completed circles, backend cards, form buttons). Then click each element with the mouse and inspect. Expected: Tabbing to any element shows a 3px indigo ring; clicking with the mouse shows no ring. Why human: focus-visible CSS pseudo-class behavior requires a real browser to distinguish pointer vs keyboard input.

3. Step transition animation

Test: Start the wizard and click Next through the steps. Expected: Each new step content performs a visible fade-in combined with a slight upward slide (8px) over approximately 200ms. Why human: CSS animation playback requires browser rendering; cannot be verified by static analysis.

4. Reduced-motion guard

Test: In OS accessibility settings (or Chrome DevTools > Rendering > Emulate CSS media feature: prefers-reduced-motion: reduce), navigate between wizard steps. Expected: Step content appears instantly with no animation; no fade or slide visible. Why human: OS-level media feature emulation requires browser/DevTools interaction.

5. Scroll-to-error in real browser

Test: In the wizard, leave the remote name field empty and click Next (or any backend card). Then on RemoteConfigStep, leave required fields empty and click Next. Expected: The page smoothly scrolls to center the first errored field in the viewport. Why human: jsdom scrollIntoView is mocked in unit tests; real scrolling behavior (visual smoothness, centering accuracy) requires a live browser with a scrollable viewport.

Gaps Summary

No gaps. All 10 observable truths are verified by static code analysis. All 4 POLISH requirements are satisfied with substantive, wired implementations. The full test suite passes (204 tests, 0 failures). The only item of note is a harmless inconsistency in FieldRenderer's select element where ring color classes still use focus: while the ring width class correctly uses focus-visible: — this has no visual impact on the POLISH-02 goal.

Six items are flagged for human verification because they involve visual rendering, responsive breakpoints, and OS-level accessibility settings that cannot be evaluated by static analysis alone.

---

Verified: 2026-04-01T13:35:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)