Ready2Blob/.planning/phases/09-md3-components/09-VERIFICATION.md

phase, verified, status, score, re_verification, human_verification

phase	verified	status	score	re_verification	human_verification
09-md3-components	2026-04-01T11:30:00Z	passed	16/16 must-haves verified	previous_status previous_score gaps_closed gaps_remaining regressions passed 12/12 Hovering the tooltip info button reveals tooltip text without clicking (hoverTooltip state + onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave) Clicking the tooltip icon pins it open; clicking again dismisses it (click-unpin clears hoverTooltip to prevent sticky state) Tooltip icon appears beside helpText below the field, not above the field (helpTextPrefix prop passed to TextFieldMD3) Tooltip icon renders even when field has tooltipText but no helpText (guard is (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error)	test expected why_human Floating label visual animation Labels in RemoteConfigStep and PasswordField inputs animate upward on focus and stay floated when a value is typed. On blur with empty field, label returns to center position. CSS :placeholder-shown pseudo-class behavior and transition animation cannot be verified with jsdom — JSDOM does not compute CSS or trigger CSS transitions. test expected why_human MD3 button visual appearance Next/Download-All buttons appear as pill-shaped (rounded-full) with primary fill color. Back/Copy/Download buttons appear as pill-shaped with an outline border and transparent background. Tailwind class presence is verified programmatically, but rendered visual output (actual computed styles, color tokens resolving correctly) requires browser inspection. test expected why_human StepIndicator visual states Step 1 shows a highlighted numbered circle (primary color ring). Completed steps show a checkmark circle. Connector lines between steps are filled (primary) for completed segments and muted (outline) for future. Dark mode renders correctly with no hardcoded colors. Semantic token resolution (bg-primary, border-outline etc.) to actual CSS custom property values requires browser rendering. test expected why_human BackendCard elevation and shape Backend cards display with visibly rounded corners (rounded-xl = 12px) and a subtle shadow. Hovering an unselected card increases shadow. Selected card has elevated shadow. Shadow rendering and hover state transitions require browser inspection. test expected why_human Tooltip icon placement (visual) Tooltip icon (ⓘ) appears visually inline to the left of helpText, below the floating-label input — not above it. On fields with no helpText, the icon still appears below the input. Flexbox inline rendering of helpTextPrefix inside TextFieldMD3 requires browser inspection to confirm correct visual position relative to input and helpText. test expected why_human Tooltip hover appearance and pin behavior (manual) Hovering the ⓘ icon on a text field shows the tooltip panel below the field. Moving the mouse away hides it. Clicking the icon pins it open; moving mouse away keeps it open. Clicking again dismisses it even while hovering. fireEvent in JSDOM verifies state logic but not actual mouse pointer interaction feel, tooltip visual positioning, or whether content is readable at that position.

Phase 9: MD3 Components Verification Report

Phase Goal: All interactive elements use MD3-styled primitives with consistent visual language across the entire wizard Verified: 2026-04-01T11:30:00Z Status: passed Re-verification: Yes — after gap closure via Plan 09-05 (commits 23617c0 and d2b6da2)

Goal Achievement

Observable Truths

#	Truth	Status	Evidence
1	TextFieldMD3 renders an outlined input with a floating label that floats on focus	VERIFIED	src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.tsx uses peer-focus:top-3 peer-focus:scale-75 CSS peer utilities
2	TextFieldMD3 floating label floats when the field has a value	VERIFIED	peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)]:top-3 peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)]:scale-75; placeholder=" " drives CSS detection
3	TextFieldMD3 preserves htmlFor/id pairing so getByLabelText queries work	VERIFIED	<label htmlFor={id}> + <input id={id}> pattern; Test 2 explicitly verifies getByLabelText
4	MD3 button class constants exist for filled, outlined, and text variants	VERIFIED	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts exports MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED, MD3_BTN_TEXT with rounded-full classes
5	FieldRenderer text-branch tooltip button uses aria-label for accessibility	VERIFIED	FieldRenderer.tsx line 92: aria-label={\More info about ${field.label}`}` on tooltip button; 4/4 DEBT-01 tests pass
6	Step indicator shows numbered circles for each wizard step	VERIFIED	StepIndicator.tsx: w-8 h-8 rounded-full spans with {i + 1} content for active/future steps
7	Completed steps display a checkmark and are clickable buttons	VERIFIED	StepIndicator.tsx: <button> with &#10003; checkmark; test confirms selector works
8	Current step is visually highlighted with primary color	VERIFIED	Active step uses border-primary bg-primary/10 text-primary font-bold — no hardcoded colors
9	Future steps appear muted	VERIFIED	Future steps use border-outline text-on-surface-container/40 semantic tokens
10	Connector lines link steps — filled for completed, muted for future	VERIFIED	bg-primary if isCompleted else bg-outline; aria-hidden="true" applied
11	Clicking step 0 dispatches SET_REMOTE_PARAMS({}) then SET_STEP(0)	VERIFIED	handleStepClick logic unchanged; StepIndicator tests verify params are cleared and deployment state preserved
12	All text inputs in the wizard render with floating labels	VERIFIED	FieldRenderer text-branch, PasswordField, and BackendSelectionStep all use TextFieldMD3
13	Hovering the tooltip icon reveals tooltip text without clicking	VERIFIED	FieldRenderer.tsx line 90-91: onMouseEnter={() => setHoverTooltip(true)} / onMouseLeave={() => setHoverTooltip(false)}; tooltipVisible = showTooltip || hoverTooltip; FieldRenderer test "hovering tooltip button shows tooltip text" passes
14	Clicking the tooltip icon pins it open; clicking again dismisses it	VERIFIED	Click handler: setShowTooltip(v => { if (v) setHoverTooltip(false); return !v; }) — clears hover on unpin to prevent sticky state; tests "pins through mouseLeave" and "clicking again dismisses" both pass
15	Tooltip icon appears beside helpText below the field, not above the field	VERIFIED	TextFieldMD3 helpTextPrefix prop renders icon inside <div className="flex items-start gap-1"> below the input; tooltipIcon passed as helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon} in FieldRenderer line 110 and PasswordField line 54
16	Tooltip icon renders even when field has tooltipText but no helpText	VERIFIED	TextFieldMD3 guard changed to (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error (line 67); Test 11 "renders helpTextPrefix alone when helpText is absent" passes

Score: 16/16 truths verified

---

Plan 09-05 Gap Closure — Truths #13–#16

Previously: COMP-04 had 4 FAILED truths related to tooltip behavior and icon placement identified in UAT session (test 7).

Now: All 4 fixed in commit 23617c0 (feat) and d2b6da2 (test):

• TextFieldMD3.tsx — added helpTextPrefix?: React.ReactNode prop; guard changed to (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error; renders <div className="flex items-start gap-1"> wrapping prefix + helpText text
• FieldRenderer.tsx — added hoverTooltip state; moved tooltip icon from above-field to tooltipIcon element passed as helpTextPrefix; select-branch also gains hover support; click-unpin clears hoverTooltip
• PasswordField.tsx — same dual-state tooltip fix as FieldRenderer text-branch

7 new tests added (4 in FieldRenderer.test.tsx hover suite, 3 in TextFieldMD3.test.tsx Tests 9-11). All 186 tests pass.

---

Required Artifacts

Artifact	Expected	Status	Details
src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.tsx	MD3 outlined text field with CSS floating label and helpTextPrefix slot	VERIFIED	82 lines; exports TextFieldMD3; helpTextPrefix?: React.ReactNode in interface (line 10); guard (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error (line 67)
src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.test.tsx	Unit tests including helpTextPrefix behavior	VERIFIED	11 tests (Tests 1-11); Tests 9-11 cover helpTextPrefix combinations
src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	MD3 button class constants	VERIFIED	Exports MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED, MD3_BTN_TEXT as string constants
src/components/ui/FieldRenderer.test.tsx	Tests for DEBT-01 aria-label consistency and tooltip hover behavior	VERIFIED	8 tests total — 4 hover behavior tests + 4 DEBT-01 aria-label tests
src/components/wizard/StepIndicator.tsx	Rebuilt MD3 step indicator with circles and connectors	VERIFIED	Exports StepIndicator, uses useWizard() for state and dispatch
src/components/ui/FieldRenderer.tsx	Text-branch using TextFieldMD3 with tooltip below field via helpTextPrefix	VERIFIED	hoverTooltip state (line 15); tooltipIcon element (lines 86-97); helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon} (line 110); select-branch has onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave (lines 53-54)
src/components/ui/PasswordField.tsx	Password field with tooltip below via helpTextPrefix and hover+click behavior	VERIFIED	hoverTooltip state (line 17); tooltipIcon element (lines 30-41); helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon} (line 54); tooltipVisible = showTooltip || hoverTooltip (line 43)
src/components/ui/BackendCard.tsx	MD3 elevation and shape	VERIFIED	rounded-xl on line 17; shadow / shadow-md / hover:shadow-md
src/components/wizard/BackendSelectionStep.tsx	All text inputs use TextFieldMD3	VERIFIED	Imports TextFieldMD3 and MD3_BTN_FILLED; TextFieldMD3 rendered for Remote name

---

Key Link Verification

From	To	Via	Status	Details
TextFieldMD3.tsx	react-hook-form	{...registration} spread onto input	VERIFIED	Line 43: {...registration} spreads UseFormRegisterReturn onto <input>
FieldRenderer.tsx	TextFieldMD3.tsx	import { TextFieldMD3 } + render with helpTextPrefix	VERIFIED	Line 5 import; line 103 renders <TextFieldMD3 helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon}>
PasswordField.tsx	TextFieldMD3.tsx	import { TextFieldMD3 } + render with helpTextPrefix and suffix	VERIFIED	Line 3 import; line 47 renders <TextFieldMD3 helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon} suffix={toggleButton}>
FieldRenderer.tsx	tooltip hover state	hoverTooltip + onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave on tooltipIcon button	VERIFIED	Lines 15, 90-91: dual-state showTooltip || hoverTooltip; click-unpin clears hover state (line 89)
PasswordField.tsx	tooltip hover state	hoverTooltip + onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave on tooltipIcon button	VERIFIED	Lines 17, 34-35: same dual-state pattern as FieldRenderer
TextFieldMD3.tsx	helpTextPrefix slot	(helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error guard + flex wrapper	VERIFIED	Line 67: guard enables prefix-only rendering; line 68-73: <div className="flex items-start gap-1"> wraps prefix and helpText
BackendSelectionStep.tsx	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	import { MD3_BTN_FILLED }	VERIFIED	Applied to Next button
RemoteConfigStep.tsx	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }	VERIFIED	Applied to Back/Next buttons
DeploymentStep.tsx	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }	VERIFIED	Applied to Back/Next buttons
ReviewStep.tsx	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }	VERIFIED	Back = OUTLINED, Download All = FILLED
OutputBlock.tsx	src/styles/md3-buttons.ts	import { MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }	VERIFIED	smallBtn constant uses MD3_BTN_OUTLINED with size overrides
StepIndicator.tsx	src/store/context.tsx	useWizard() for state.currentStep and dispatch	VERIFIED	const { state, dispatch } = useWizard()

---

Requirements Coverage

Requirement	Source Plan(s)	Description	Status	Evidence
COMP-01	09-01, 09-03, 09-04	All text inputs render as MD3 outlined text fields with floating labels that animate on focus and when the field has content	VERIFIED	FieldRenderer text-branch, PasswordField, and BackendSelectionStep all use TextFieldMD3. No plain label+input blocks remain in wizard step files.
COMP-02	09-03	Buttons follow MD3 hierarchy — filled for primary actions, outlined for secondary	VERIFIED	All 4 wizard steps + OutputBlock import and apply MD3_BTN_FILLED / MD3_BTN_OUTLINED correctly
COMP-03	09-03	Cards and output blocks use MD3 elevation with shape tokens	VERIFIED	BackendCard: rounded-xl + shadow/shadow-md; OutputBlock pre: rounded-xl shadow-sm
COMP-04	09-02, 09-05	Step indicator shows numbered circles with checkmarks, highlighted current, muted future; tooltip icon beside helpText below field, hover reveals tooltip	VERIFIED	StepIndicator rebuilt with circles, connector lines, semantic tokens; tooltip placement and hover behavior fixed in Plan 09-05 — all 4 gap truths (#13–#16) now pass; 186/186 tests pass
DEBT-01	09-01	FieldRenderer uses consistent aria-label pattern across text-branch and select-branch	VERIFIED	Both branches and PasswordField use aria-label={\More info about ${field.label}`}` pattern; 4/4 tests pass

REQUIREMENTS.md Traceability Cross-Check: All 5 IDs (COMP-01, COMP-02, COMP-03, COMP-04, DEBT-01) are mapped to Phase 9 in REQUIREMENTS.md with status "Complete". All 5 are VERIFIED with full evidence. No orphaned requirements found.

---

Anti-Patterns Found

File	Line	Pattern	Severity	Impact
src/components/wizard/ReviewStep.tsx	16, 27	PLACEHOLDER constant	Info	Legitimate empty-state UX string, not a stub — renders when config cannot be built

No TODO/FIXME/HACK comments found in plan 09-05 modified files. No hardcoded hex color codes. No return null / return {} stubs.

---

Human Verification Required

1. Floating Label CSS Animation

Test: Navigate to BackendSelectionStep (step 1). Click into the Remote name field, then click away without typing. Then type a value, blur, then clear it. Expected: On focus, the label smoothly translates upward and scales to 75%. When a value is present and the field is blurred, the label stays floated. When the value is cleared, the label returns to center. Verify the same behavior in RemoteConfigStep and PasswordField. Why human: JSDOM does not compute CSS transitions or :placeholder-shown pseudo-class behavior. The Tailwind peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)] arbitrary variant is untested by jsdom.

2. MD3 Button Visual Appearance

Test: Navigate through all wizard steps and observe button appearances at each step. Expected: Next/Download-All = pill shape with solid primary background color. Back/Copy/Download = pill shape with a visible outline border and no fill. Disabled state shows reduced opacity. Why human: MD3_BTN_* class strings are applied correctly (verified), but the visual rendering of semantic tokens (bg-primary, border-outline, etc.) requires actual CSS custom property resolution in a browser.

3. StepIndicator Visual States in Browser

Test: Complete step 1 (Backend selection) and observe the step indicator. Expected: Step 1 circle shows a checkmark and is clickable. Step 2 circle is highlighted with a primary color border/background. Steps 3 and 4 appear muted. The connector line between steps 1 and 2 is filled (primary color); between 2-3 and 3-4 it is muted. Why human: Semantic token resolution and visual differentiation of states requires browser rendering.

4. Dark Mode Consistency

Test: Toggle to dark mode and navigate through all wizard steps. Expected: All MD3 components render correctly with no hardcoded colors bleeding through. Floating label color changes on focus/error still work. Card shadows remain visible but subtle. Why human: CSS custom property values under the dark theme class cannot be verified without rendering.

5. Tooltip Icon Placement (Visual)

Test: Open a step that has fields with tooltipText (e.g., RemoteConfigStep with Azure Blob SAS URL field). Inspect the position of the ⓘ icon relative to the input and any helpText. Expected: The ⓘ icon appears below the input, inline to the left of the helpText (or alone below the input if there is no helpText). It does NOT appear above the input floating-label area. Why human: The helpTextPrefix slot renders inside a <div className="flex items-start gap-1"> below the input — flexbox layout and visual position must be confirmed in a real browser.

6. Tooltip Hover and Pin Behavior (Manual)

Test: Move the mouse over the ⓘ icon on a field with tooltipText. Then move the mouse away. Then click and move away. Then click again while still hovering. Expected: Hover shows tooltip, mouse-leave hides it. Click pins it open so mouse-leave no longer hides it. Second click while hovering dismisses the tooltip completely (no sticky state). Why human: fireEvent in JSDOM verifies state transitions correctly, but actual mouse pointer UX (timing, visual feedback of hover vs. pinned state, tooltip readability at that position) requires manual validation in a browser.

---

Summary

Plan 09-05 (commits 23617c0 and d2b6da2) fully closed all 4 tooltip-related gaps identified in the UAT session:

1. helpTextPrefix prop added to TextFieldMD3 — enables inline slot left of helpText below the input.
2. Guard changed to (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error — tooltip icon renders even without helpText.
3. Tooltip icon moved from above-field position to helpTextPrefix slot below the input in both FieldRenderer and PasswordField.
4. Dual-state hover+click: onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave drive hoverTooltip; click toggles showTooltip; click-unpin explicitly clears hoverTooltip to prevent sticky-after-dismiss edge case.
5. Select-branch in FieldRenderer also received hover support (onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave).

All 16 must-have truths are VERIFIED. All 5 requirements (COMP-01, COMP-02, COMP-03, COMP-04, DEBT-01) are fully satisfied. The full test suite (186 tests across 15 files) passes with zero regressions.

Six items remain flagged for human verification — all relate to CSS animation, visual token resolution, visual tooltip placement, and interactive hover feel that cannot be confirmed programmatically.

---

Verified: 2026-04-01T11:30:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier) Re-verification after gap closure via Plan 09-05 (commits 23617c0, d2b6da2)