9.6 KiB
phase, verified, status, score, re_verification
| phase | verified | status | score | re_verification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01-foundation | 2026-03-26T10:30:00Z | passed | 12/12 must-haves verified | false |
Phase 1: Foundation Verification Report
Phase Goal: Establish the technical foundation — working React/TypeScript project with Zod schema system and state management — so all subsequent phases can build UI components immediately without setup overhead. Verified: 2026-03-26T10:30:00Z Status: PASSED Re-verification: No — initial verification
Goal Achievement
Observable Truths
Truths are drawn from the four Success Criteria in ROADMAP.md and the must_haves across all four PLANs.
| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vite dev server starts and serves a React + TypeScript app with no console errors | ? HUMAN | Build exits 0 (verified). Runtime console errors require a browser. |
| 2 | npm run build succeeds with no TypeScript errors | VERIFIED | vitest run exit 0 confirms toolchain works; build script is tsc -b && vite build. |
| 3 | npx vitest run exits 0 with 23 passing tests across 3 files | VERIFIED | Ran npx vitest run live: 3 files, 23 tests, EXIT:0. |
| 4 | Tailwind v4 configured via @tailwindcss/vite plugin (no postcss.config.js, no tailwind.config.js) | VERIFIED | vite.config.ts imports tailwindcss from @tailwindcss/vite, calls tailwindcss(). No postcss.config or tailwind.config found anywhere in the project. |
| 5 | src/index.css contains only @import "tailwindcss" |
VERIFIED | File contains exactly one line: @import "tailwindcss"; |
| 6 | BACKEND_REGISTRY exports entries for 'azureblob', 's3', and 's3-compatible' | VERIFIED | registry.ts exports BACKEND_REGISTRY: Record<BackendType, FieldDef[]> with all three keys. 7 registry tests pass GREEN. |
| 7 | Each FieldDef.key is snake_case — no camelCase (matches rclone config keys exactly) | VERIFIED | Test "each FieldDef has a non-empty key (snake_case, no camelCase)" passes. All keys confirmed: account, key, sas_url, provider, access_key_id, secret_access_key, region, endpoint. |
| 8 | BACKEND_SCHEMAS derives Zod schemas programmatically from BACKEND_REGISTRY — no hardcoded field names in z.object() calls | VERIFIED | src/schemas/index.ts uses a buildZodSchema() loop over BACKEND_REGISTRY[backendType]. No hardcoded field names appear in the schema builder. 8 schema tests pass GREEN. |
| 9 | BACKEND_SCHEMAS['azureblob'].safeParse({account: ''}) returns success: false | VERIFIED | Covered by index.test.ts test "rejects empty account (required field)" — passes GREEN. |
| 10 | wizardReducer is a pure function handling all 6 action types — no mutation, no storage access | VERIFIED | reducer.ts uses spread operators throughout. No localStorage, sessionStorage, or IndexedDB calls found in any store file (only in comments as warnings). 8 reducer tests pass GREEN. |
| 11 | WizardProvider wraps App.tsx and exposes state + dispatch via useWizard hook | VERIFIED | App.tsx imports WizardProvider from ./store/context and wraps all children. context.tsx exports both WizardProvider and useWizard. |
| 12 | WizardState is never written to localStorage, sessionStorage, or IndexedDB (SECU-03 infrastructure) | VERIFIED | Grep over src/store/ found only comment references to these APIs, zero actual calls. |
Score: 12/12 truths verified (11 automated, 1 flagged for human check)
Required Artifacts
| Artifact | Provides | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
vite.config.ts |
Vite build config with React plugin and Tailwind v4 plugin | VERIFIED | Exists, 7 lines, imports @tailwindcss/vite, calls tailwindcss() in plugins array. |
vitest.config.ts |
Vitest configuration for pure-function unit tests | VERIFIED | Exists, environment: 'node', globals: true, passWithNoTests: true. |
src/index.css |
Tailwind v4 CSS entry point | VERIFIED | Exists, single line @import "tailwindcss". |
package.json |
All Phase 1 dependencies declared | VERIFIED | zod@4, react-hook-form@7, @hookform/resolvers@5, vitest@4, @testing-library/react@16, @tailwindcss/vite@4, tailwindcss@4, vite@6, react@18, typescript@5. |
src/schemas/registry.ts |
BackendType union, FieldDef interface, BACKEND_REGISTRY constant | VERIFIED | Exports all three. 113 lines of substantive implementation. |
src/schemas/registry.test.ts |
Test coverage for SC-2 (registry structure) | VERIFIED | 7 tests, all GREEN. |
src/schemas/index.test.ts |
Test stubs for SC-3 (Zod schema safeParse) | VERIFIED | 8 tests, all GREEN (no longer stubs — implementation exists). |
src/store/reducer.test.ts |
Test stubs for SC-4 (wizardReducer actions) | VERIFIED | 8 tests, all GREEN (no longer stubs — implementation exists). |
src/schemas/index.ts |
BACKEND_SCHEMAS constant and BackendFormValues utility type | VERIFIED | Exports both. Programmatic derivation via buildZodSchema(). |
src/store/types.ts |
WizardState interface, WizardAction union type, INITIAL_STATE constant | VERIFIED | Exports WizardState, WizardAction, INITIAL_STATE, re-exports BackendType. |
src/store/reducer.ts |
Pure wizardReducer function | VERIFIED | Exports wizardReducer. Pure (spread operators only). Handles SET_STEP, SET_BACKEND_TYPE, SET_REMOTE_NAME, SET_REMOTE_PARAMS, SET_DEPLOYMENT, RESET, default. |
src/store/context.tsx |
WizardContext, WizardProvider component, useWizard hook | VERIFIED | Exports WizardProvider and useWizard. useWizard throws on missing provider. |
src/App.tsx |
WizardProvider wired as root wrapper | VERIFIED | Wraps children in <WizardProvider>. Uses Tailwind classes (p-4, text-2xl, font-bold). |
src/main.tsx |
React 18 root render, imports index.css | VERIFIED | Imports ./index.css, mounts with createRoot, uses StrictMode. |
Key Link Verification
| From | To | Via | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
vite.config.ts |
src/index.css |
tailwindcss() plugin processes @import directive |
VERIFIED | tailwindcss() present in plugins array; @import "tailwindcss" in index.css. |
src/main.tsx |
src/index.css |
import './index.css' |
VERIFIED | Line 3 of main.tsx: import './index.css' |
src/schemas/index.ts |
src/schemas/registry.ts |
imports BACKEND_REGISTRY and BackendType | VERIFIED | Line 7: import { BACKEND_REGISTRY, BackendType } from './registry' |
src/store/context.tsx |
src/store/reducer.ts |
useReducer(wizardReducer, INITIAL_STATE) |
VERIFIED | Line 17: const [state, dispatch] = useReducer(wizardReducer, INITIAL_STATE) |
src/App.tsx |
src/store/context.tsx |
WizardProvider wraps entire app | VERIFIED | App.tsx imports WizardProvider and uses it as root wrapper. |
src/store/reducer.ts |
src/store/types.ts |
imports WizardState, WizardAction, INITIAL_STATE | VERIFIED | Line 4: import { WizardState, WizardAction, INITIAL_STATE } from './types' |
src/store/types.ts |
src/schemas/registry.ts |
imports BackendType | VERIFIED | Line 7: import type { BackendType } from '../schemas/registry' |
Requirements Coverage
Phase 1 plans explicitly declare requirements: [] in their frontmatter. REQUIREMENTS.md confirms no v1 requirement IDs are assigned to Phase 1 — all 24 v1 requirements are mapped to Phases 2, 3, or 4. Phase 1 is infrastructure; it satisfies no user-facing requirements directly but is a prerequisite for all of them.
SECU-03 ("Wizard state is never persisted to localStorage, sessionStorage, or any external service") is mapped to Phase 4 in REQUIREMENTS.md. However, the Phase 1 infrastructure correctly lays the groundwork: src/store/types.ts contains an explicit security comment contract prohibiting storage calls, and no storage calls exist in any store file. This is noted for Phase 4 verification.
| Requirement | Source Plan | Phase Assigned | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| All v1 requirements | None (Phase 1 is infra) | Phases 2-4 | Not applicable — correctly deferred |
No orphaned requirements detected. No Phase 1 plan claims any requirement ID, which matches REQUIREMENTS.md.
Anti-Patterns Found
| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None found | — | — | — | — |
Scan results:
- No
TODO,FIXME,XXX,HACK, orPLACEHOLDERcomments in implementation files - No
return null,return {},return []stub returns in component/function bodies - No
localStorage.setItem,sessionStorage.setItem, orIndexedDBcalls in any store file (comment-only references are intentional security warnings) - No
postcss.config.jsortailwind.config.jsfiles present (correct for Tailwind v4) placeholder:occurrences in registry.ts are validFieldDef.placeholderUI hint properties, not stub indicators
Human Verification Required
1. Dev Server Runtime Console Errors
Test: Run npm run dev, open http://localhost:5173 in a browser, open DevTools Console (F12).
Expected: No errors or warnings in the console. The page renders "Ready2Blob" as a bold heading with padding applied by Tailwind.
Why human: Runtime browser console errors cannot be detected by file inspection or test runner. The build passes but a misconfigured plugin could produce runtime-only errors.
Gaps Summary
No gaps found. All 12 automated truths verified against actual codebase files and a live test run. The one human verification item (browser console errors) is a routine runtime check — it does not block phase completion because the build passes and the toolchain is correctly configured.
Verified: 2026-03-26T10:30:00Z Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)