---
phase: 09-md3-components
verified: 2026-04-01T11:30:00Z
status: passed
score: 16/16 must-haves verified
re_verification:
  previous_status: passed
  previous_score: 12/12
  gaps_closed:
    - "Hovering the tooltip info button reveals tooltip text without clicking (hoverTooltip state + onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave)"
    - "Clicking the tooltip icon pins it open; clicking again dismisses it (click-unpin clears hoverTooltip to prevent sticky state)"
    - "Tooltip icon appears beside helpText below the field, not above the field (helpTextPrefix prop passed to TextFieldMD3)"
    - "Tooltip icon renders even when field has tooltipText but no helpText (guard is (helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error)"
  gaps_remaining: []
  regressions: []
human_verification:
  - test: "Floating label visual animation"
    expected: "Labels in RemoteConfigStep and PasswordField inputs animate upward on focus and stay floated when a value is typed. On blur with empty field, label returns to center position."
    why_human: "CSS :placeholder-shown pseudo-class behavior and transition animation cannot be verified with jsdom — JSDOM does not compute CSS or trigger CSS transitions."
  - test: "MD3 button visual appearance"
    expected: "Next/Download-All buttons appear as pill-shaped (rounded-full) with primary fill color. Back/Copy/Download buttons appear as pill-shaped with an outline border and transparent background."
    why_human: "Tailwind class presence is verified programmatically, but rendered visual output (actual computed styles, color tokens resolving correctly) requires browser inspection."
  - test: "StepIndicator visual states"
    expected: "Step 1 shows a highlighted numbered circle (primary color ring). Completed steps show a checkmark circle. Connector lines between steps are filled (primary) for completed segments and muted (outline) for future. Dark mode renders correctly with no hardcoded colors."
    why_human: "Semantic token resolution (bg-primary, border-outline etc.) to actual CSS custom property values requires browser rendering."
  - test: "BackendCard elevation and shape"
    expected: "Backend cards display with visibly rounded corners (rounded-xl = 12px) and a subtle shadow. Hovering an unselected card increases shadow. Selected card has elevated shadow."
    why_human: "Shadow rendering and hover state transitions require browser inspection."
  - test: "Tooltip icon placement (visual)"
    expected: "Tooltip icon (ⓘ) appears visually inline to the left of helpText, below the floating-label input — not above it. On fields with no helpText, the icon still appears below the input."
    why_human: "Flexbox inline rendering of helpTextPrefix inside TextFieldMD3 requires browser inspection to confirm correct visual position relative to input and helpText."
  - test: "Tooltip hover appearance and pin behavior (manual)"
    expected: "Hovering the ⓘ icon on a text field shows the tooltip panel below the field. Moving the mouse away hides it. Clicking the icon pins it open; moving mouse away keeps it open. Clicking again dismisses it even while hovering."
    why_human: "fireEvent in JSDOM verifies state logic but not actual mouse pointer interaction feel, tooltip visual positioning, or whether content is readable at that position."
---

# Phase 9: MD3 Components Verification Report

**Phase Goal:** All interactive elements use MD3-styled primitives with consistent visual language across the entire wizard
**Verified:** 2026-04-01T11:30:00Z
**Status:** passed
**Re-verification:** Yes — after gap closure via Plan 09-05 (commits 23617c0 and d2b6da2)

## Goal Achievement

### Observable Truths

| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| 1 | TextFieldMD3 renders an outlined input with a floating label that floats on focus | VERIFIED | `src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.tsx` uses `peer-focus:top-3 peer-focus:scale-75` CSS peer utilities |
| 2 | TextFieldMD3 floating label floats when the field has a value | VERIFIED | `peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)]:top-3 peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)]:scale-75`; `placeholder=" "` drives CSS detection |
| 3 | TextFieldMD3 preserves htmlFor/id pairing so getByLabelText queries work | VERIFIED | `<label htmlFor={id}>` + `<input id={id}>` pattern; Test 2 explicitly verifies `getByLabelText` |
| 4 | MD3 button class constants exist for filled, outlined, and text variants | VERIFIED | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` exports `MD3_BTN_FILLED`, `MD3_BTN_OUTLINED`, `MD3_BTN_TEXT` with `rounded-full` classes |
| 5 | FieldRenderer text-branch tooltip button uses aria-label for accessibility | VERIFIED | FieldRenderer.tsx line 92: `aria-label={\`More info about \${field.label}\`}` on tooltip button; 4/4 DEBT-01 tests pass |
| 6 | Step indicator shows numbered circles for each wizard step | VERIFIED | StepIndicator.tsx: `w-8 h-8 rounded-full` spans with `{i + 1}` content for active/future steps |
| 7 | Completed steps display a checkmark and are clickable buttons | VERIFIED | StepIndicator.tsx: `<button>` with `&#10003;` checkmark; test confirms selector works |
| 8 | Current step is visually highlighted with primary color | VERIFIED | Active step uses `border-primary bg-primary/10 text-primary font-bold` — no hardcoded colors |
| 9 | Future steps appear muted | VERIFIED | Future steps use `border-outline text-on-surface-container/40` semantic tokens |
| 10 | Connector lines link steps — filled for completed, muted for future | VERIFIED | `bg-primary` if `isCompleted` else `bg-outline`; `aria-hidden="true"` applied |
| 11 | Clicking step 0 dispatches SET_REMOTE_PARAMS({}) then SET_STEP(0) | VERIFIED | `handleStepClick` logic unchanged; StepIndicator tests verify params are cleared and deployment state preserved |
| 12 | All text inputs in the wizard render with floating labels | VERIFIED | FieldRenderer text-branch, PasswordField, and BackendSelectionStep all use TextFieldMD3 |
| 13 | Hovering the tooltip icon reveals tooltip text without clicking | VERIFIED | FieldRenderer.tsx line 90-91: `onMouseEnter={() => setHoverTooltip(true)}` / `onMouseLeave={() => setHoverTooltip(false)}`; `tooltipVisible = showTooltip \|\| hoverTooltip`; FieldRenderer test "hovering tooltip button shows tooltip text" passes |
| 14 | Clicking the tooltip icon pins it open; clicking again dismisses it | VERIFIED | Click handler: `setShowTooltip(v => { if (v) setHoverTooltip(false); return !v; })` — clears hover on unpin to prevent sticky state; tests "pins through mouseLeave" and "clicking again dismisses" both pass |
| 15 | Tooltip icon appears beside helpText below the field, not above the field | VERIFIED | TextFieldMD3 `helpTextPrefix` prop renders icon inside `<div className="flex items-start gap-1">` below the input; `tooltipIcon` passed as `helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon}` in FieldRenderer line 110 and PasswordField line 54 |
| 16 | Tooltip icon renders even when field has tooltipText but no helpText | VERIFIED | TextFieldMD3 guard changed to `(helpText \|\| helpTextPrefix) && !error` (line 67); Test 11 "renders helpTextPrefix alone when helpText is absent" passes |

**Score: 16/16 truths verified**

---

### Plan 09-05 Gap Closure — Truths #13–#16

**Previously:** COMP-04 had 4 FAILED truths related to tooltip behavior and icon placement identified in UAT session (test 7).

**Now:** All 4 fixed in commit `23617c0` (feat) and `d2b6da2` (test):

- `TextFieldMD3.tsx` — added `helpTextPrefix?: React.ReactNode` prop; guard changed to `(helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error`; renders `<div className="flex items-start gap-1">` wrapping prefix + helpText text
- `FieldRenderer.tsx` — added `hoverTooltip` state; moved tooltip icon from above-field to `tooltipIcon` element passed as `helpTextPrefix`; select-branch also gains hover support; click-unpin clears hoverTooltip
- `PasswordField.tsx` — same dual-state tooltip fix as FieldRenderer text-branch

7 new tests added (4 in FieldRenderer.test.tsx hover suite, 3 in TextFieldMD3.test.tsx Tests 9-11). All 186 tests pass.

---

### Required Artifacts

| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|----------|----------|--------|---------|
| `src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.tsx` | MD3 outlined text field with CSS floating label and helpTextPrefix slot | VERIFIED | 82 lines; exports `TextFieldMD3`; `helpTextPrefix?: React.ReactNode` in interface (line 10); guard `(helpText \|\| helpTextPrefix) && !error` (line 67) |
| `src/components/ui/TextFieldMD3.test.tsx` | Unit tests including helpTextPrefix behavior | VERIFIED | 11 tests (Tests 1-11); Tests 9-11 cover helpTextPrefix combinations |
| `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | MD3 button class constants | VERIFIED | Exports `MD3_BTN_FILLED`, `MD3_BTN_OUTLINED`, `MD3_BTN_TEXT` as string constants |
| `src/components/ui/FieldRenderer.test.tsx` | Tests for DEBT-01 aria-label consistency and tooltip hover behavior | VERIFIED | 8 tests total — 4 hover behavior tests + 4 DEBT-01 aria-label tests |
| `src/components/wizard/StepIndicator.tsx` | Rebuilt MD3 step indicator with circles and connectors | VERIFIED | Exports `StepIndicator`, uses `useWizard()` for state and dispatch |
| `src/components/ui/FieldRenderer.tsx` | Text-branch using TextFieldMD3 with tooltip below field via helpTextPrefix | VERIFIED | `hoverTooltip` state (line 15); `tooltipIcon` element (lines 86-97); `helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon}` (line 110); select-branch has `onMouseEnter`/`onMouseLeave` (lines 53-54) |
| `src/components/ui/PasswordField.tsx` | Password field with tooltip below via helpTextPrefix and hover+click behavior | VERIFIED | `hoverTooltip` state (line 17); `tooltipIcon` element (lines 30-41); `helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon}` (line 54); `tooltipVisible = showTooltip \|\| hoverTooltip` (line 43) |
| `src/components/ui/BackendCard.tsx` | MD3 elevation and shape | VERIFIED | `rounded-xl` on line 17; `shadow` / `shadow-md` / `hover:shadow-md` |
| `src/components/wizard/BackendSelectionStep.tsx` | All text inputs use TextFieldMD3 | VERIFIED | Imports `TextFieldMD3` and `MD3_BTN_FILLED`; TextFieldMD3 rendered for Remote name |

---

### Key Link Verification

| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|------|----|-----|--------|---------|
| `TextFieldMD3.tsx` | `react-hook-form` | `{...registration}` spread onto input | VERIFIED | Line 43: `{...registration}` spreads `UseFormRegisterReturn` onto `<input>` |
| `FieldRenderer.tsx` | `TextFieldMD3.tsx` | `import { TextFieldMD3 }` + render with `helpTextPrefix` | VERIFIED | Line 5 import; line 103 renders `<TextFieldMD3 helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon}>` |
| `PasswordField.tsx` | `TextFieldMD3.tsx` | `import { TextFieldMD3 }` + render with `helpTextPrefix` and `suffix` | VERIFIED | Line 3 import; line 47 renders `<TextFieldMD3 helpTextPrefix={tooltipIcon} suffix={toggleButton}>` |
| `FieldRenderer.tsx` | tooltip hover state | `hoverTooltip` + `onMouseEnter`/`onMouseLeave` on `tooltipIcon` button | VERIFIED | Lines 15, 90-91: dual-state `showTooltip \|\| hoverTooltip`; click-unpin clears hover state (line 89) |
| `PasswordField.tsx` | tooltip hover state | `hoverTooltip` + `onMouseEnter`/`onMouseLeave` on `tooltipIcon` button | VERIFIED | Lines 17, 34-35: same dual-state pattern as FieldRenderer |
| `TextFieldMD3.tsx` | `helpTextPrefix` slot | `(helpText \|\| helpTextPrefix) && !error` guard + flex wrapper | VERIFIED | Line 67: guard enables prefix-only rendering; line 68-73: `<div className="flex items-start gap-1">` wraps prefix and helpText |
| `BackendSelectionStep.tsx` | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | `import { MD3_BTN_FILLED }` | VERIFIED | Applied to Next button |
| `RemoteConfigStep.tsx` | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | `import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }` | VERIFIED | Applied to Back/Next buttons |
| `DeploymentStep.tsx` | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | `import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }` | VERIFIED | Applied to Back/Next buttons |
| `ReviewStep.tsx` | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | `import { MD3_BTN_FILLED, MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }` | VERIFIED | Back = OUTLINED, Download All = FILLED |
| `OutputBlock.tsx` | `src/styles/md3-buttons.ts` | `import { MD3_BTN_OUTLINED }` | VERIFIED | `smallBtn` constant uses `MD3_BTN_OUTLINED` with size overrides |
| `StepIndicator.tsx` | `src/store/context.tsx` | `useWizard()` for state.currentStep and dispatch | VERIFIED | `const { state, dispatch } = useWizard()` |

---

### Requirements Coverage

| Requirement | Source Plan(s) | Description | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|---------------|-------------|--------|----------|
| COMP-01 | 09-01, 09-03, 09-04 | All text inputs render as MD3 outlined text fields with floating labels that animate on focus and when the field has content | VERIFIED | FieldRenderer text-branch, PasswordField, and BackendSelectionStep all use TextFieldMD3. No plain label+input blocks remain in wizard step files. |
| COMP-02 | 09-03 | Buttons follow MD3 hierarchy — filled for primary actions, outlined for secondary | VERIFIED | All 4 wizard steps + OutputBlock import and apply `MD3_BTN_FILLED` / `MD3_BTN_OUTLINED` correctly |
| COMP-03 | 09-03 | Cards and output blocks use MD3 elevation with shape tokens | VERIFIED | BackendCard: `rounded-xl` + `shadow`/`shadow-md`; OutputBlock pre: `rounded-xl shadow-sm` |
| COMP-04 | 09-02, 09-05 | Step indicator shows numbered circles with checkmarks, highlighted current, muted future; tooltip icon beside helpText below field, hover reveals tooltip | VERIFIED | StepIndicator rebuilt with circles, connector lines, semantic tokens; tooltip placement and hover behavior fixed in Plan 09-05 — all 4 gap truths (#13–#16) now pass; 186/186 tests pass |
| DEBT-01 | 09-01 | FieldRenderer uses consistent aria-label pattern across text-branch and select-branch | VERIFIED | Both branches and PasswordField use `aria-label={\`More info about \${field.label}\`}` pattern; 4/4 tests pass |

**REQUIREMENTS.md Traceability Cross-Check:**
All 5 IDs (COMP-01, COMP-02, COMP-03, COMP-04, DEBT-01) are mapped to Phase 9 in REQUIREMENTS.md with status "Complete". All 5 are VERIFIED with full evidence. No orphaned requirements found.

---

### Anti-Patterns Found

| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|------|------|---------|----------|--------|
| `src/components/wizard/ReviewStep.tsx` | 16, 27 | `PLACEHOLDER` constant | Info | Legitimate empty-state UX string, not a stub — renders when config cannot be built |

No TODO/FIXME/HACK comments found in plan 09-05 modified files. No hardcoded hex color codes. No `return null` / `return {}` stubs.

---

### Human Verification Required

#### 1. Floating Label CSS Animation

**Test:** Navigate to BackendSelectionStep (step 1). Click into the Remote name field, then click away without typing. Then type a value, blur, then clear it.
**Expected:** On focus, the label smoothly translates upward and scales to 75%. When a value is present and the field is blurred, the label stays floated. When the value is cleared, the label returns to center. Verify the same behavior in RemoteConfigStep and PasswordField.
**Why human:** JSDOM does not compute CSS transitions or `:placeholder-shown` pseudo-class behavior. The Tailwind `peer-[:not(:placeholder-shown)]` arbitrary variant is untested by jsdom.

#### 2. MD3 Button Visual Appearance

**Test:** Navigate through all wizard steps and observe button appearances at each step.
**Expected:** Next/Download-All = pill shape with solid primary background color. Back/Copy/Download = pill shape with a visible outline border and no fill. Disabled state shows reduced opacity.
**Why human:** `MD3_BTN_*` class strings are applied correctly (verified), but the visual rendering of semantic tokens (`bg-primary`, `border-outline`, etc.) requires actual CSS custom property resolution in a browser.

#### 3. StepIndicator Visual States in Browser

**Test:** Complete step 1 (Backend selection) and observe the step indicator.
**Expected:** Step 1 circle shows a checkmark and is clickable. Step 2 circle is highlighted with a primary color border/background. Steps 3 and 4 appear muted. The connector line between steps 1 and 2 is filled (primary color); between 2-3 and 3-4 it is muted.
**Why human:** Semantic token resolution and visual differentiation of states requires browser rendering.

#### 4. Dark Mode Consistency

**Test:** Toggle to dark mode and navigate through all wizard steps.
**Expected:** All MD3 components render correctly with no hardcoded colors bleeding through. Floating label color changes on focus/error still work. Card shadows remain visible but subtle.
**Why human:** CSS custom property values under the dark theme class cannot be verified without rendering.

#### 5. Tooltip Icon Placement (Visual)

**Test:** Open a step that has fields with `tooltipText` (e.g., RemoteConfigStep with Azure Blob SAS URL field). Inspect the position of the ⓘ icon relative to the input and any helpText.
**Expected:** The ⓘ icon appears below the input, inline to the left of the helpText (or alone below the input if there is no helpText). It does NOT appear above the input floating-label area.
**Why human:** The `helpTextPrefix` slot renders inside a `<div className="flex items-start gap-1">` below the input — flexbox layout and visual position must be confirmed in a real browser.

#### 6. Tooltip Hover and Pin Behavior (Manual)

**Test:** Move the mouse over the ⓘ icon on a field with `tooltipText`. Then move the mouse away. Then click and move away. Then click again while still hovering.
**Expected:** Hover shows tooltip, mouse-leave hides it. Click pins it open so mouse-leave no longer hides it. Second click while hovering dismisses the tooltip completely (no sticky state).
**Why human:** `fireEvent` in JSDOM verifies state transitions correctly, but actual mouse pointer UX (timing, visual feedback of hover vs. pinned state, tooltip readability at that position) requires manual validation in a browser.

---

### Summary

Plan 09-05 (commits `23617c0` and `d2b6da2`) fully closed all 4 tooltip-related gaps identified in the UAT session:

1. `helpTextPrefix` prop added to TextFieldMD3 — enables inline slot left of helpText below the input.
2. Guard changed to `(helpText || helpTextPrefix) && !error` — tooltip icon renders even without helpText.
3. Tooltip icon moved from above-field position to `helpTextPrefix` slot below the input in both FieldRenderer and PasswordField.
4. Dual-state hover+click: `onMouseEnter`/`onMouseLeave` drive `hoverTooltip`; click toggles `showTooltip`; click-unpin explicitly clears `hoverTooltip` to prevent sticky-after-dismiss edge case.
5. Select-branch in FieldRenderer also received hover support (onMouseEnter/onMouseLeave).

All 16 must-have truths are VERIFIED. All 5 requirements (COMP-01, COMP-02, COMP-03, COMP-04, DEBT-01) are fully satisfied. The full test suite (186 tests across 15 files) passes with zero regressions.

Six items remain flagged for human verification — all relate to CSS animation, visual token resolution, visual tooltip placement, and interactive hover feel that cannot be confirmed programmatically.

---

_Verified: 2026-04-01T11:30:00Z_
_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)_
_Re-verification after gap closure via Plan 09-05 (commits 23617c0, d2b6da2)_